Yemen: the secret French arms shipments

By Disclose

Amid the ongoing war in Yemen, France continued to supply weapons to, and also signed new contracts with, Saudi Arabia, all of it behind a veil of secrecy.

This article is freely available. Check out our subscription offers. Subscribe

The CAESER is one of the most powerful weapons France has sold to Saudi Arabia. Manufactured by Nexter, an entirely state-owned French defence company, it is an artillery piece made up of a mighty gun mounted on an all-wheel-drive truck chassis. It is now suspected that the CAESER units exported to Saudi Arabia are being used to shell zones in Yemen which are inhabited by hundreds of thousands of people (see our first report). The French government, despite knowing of the risks of this, continues to supply the weapon. No less than 147 CAESERs are due to be delivered to Saudi Arabia between now and 2023. 

Disclose has traced the path of one of these deliveries, carried out in September 2018.

The journey began one morning in September 2018, in the town of Roanne, in central France, where Nexter’s production plant is based. It was from there that at least ten CAESER guns were sent 587 kilometres north to the Channel port of Le Havre. After arrival at the port, they were loaded into the cargo hold of a freighter called Bahri Jazan, operated by Saudi Arabia’s national transport company Bahri. The freighter lifted anchor on September 24th, arriving 19 days later in the Saudi port of Jeddah, its final destination.

Above: using satellite images and information obtained from open sources, Disclose has produced a video of the itinerary of the CAESAR guns delivered to Saudi Arabia at the end of 2018.(in French). © Disclose

  • A new contract with Saudi Arabia

The codename is ARTIS. These five letters are rarely pronounced within Nexter, the leading European manufacturer of terrestrial weapons, and when they are it is only under the veil of secrecy. This new export contract, signed off in December 2018, again places the French executive in face of its contradictions. On October 30th 2018, French defence minister Florence Parly told news channel BFMTV: “We have no ongoing negotiations with Saudi Arabia.” But at that very same date, the French government was involved in negotiations over the final details of the contract with Saudi Arabia, which covered a period lasting up to 2023.  

Against the backdrop of the war in Yemen, Nexter and the French government refrained from any public announcement about the contract. The word had been sent out to all concerned to be as discreet as possible about ARTIS; the recipient country should never appear in communications, either internal or external. However, the contract does indeed appear on the “hunting list” of the company, as Nexter CEO Stéphane Mayer boasted within the company's offices.

Disclose has obtained a confidential document handed out during a meeting of Nexter’s economic commission in February this year. It is headed “Context and strategic orientations”, and represents one of the rare pieces of evidence of the existence of the ARTIS contract (document below).

nexter

A second document (see below), whose understated title is “Delivery plans”, details the equipment to be sent to Saudi Arabia between 2019 and 2024. This includes the armoured infantry carrier Titus, one of the latest of Nexter’s products, and also a towed howitzer, the 105LG, which are both part of the ARTIS contract.

Contacted by Disclose, Nexter did not respond to our request for an interview.

 

Above: Nexter's report, “Delivery plans”, detailing military exports to Saudi Arabia between 2019 and 2024. Above: Nexter's report, “Delivery plans”, detailing military exports to Saudi Arabia between 2019 and 2024.

“The success of the ARTIS contract is politically sensitive,” said a Nexter employee, who spoke on condition their name was withheld. Indeed, NGOs which include Amnesty International, anti-corruption organisation Sherpa and also Oxfam France, are keen to identify the weapons sold to a country which the United Nations (UN) suspect of committing war crimes. But also interested in the issue is member of the French parliament (MP) Sébastien Nadot, a former member of President Macron’s LREM party and now affiliated to a separate “Progressist Movement” group, who has over many months called for a parliamentary inquiry into the arms exports, along with other MPs from the radical-left La France insoumise (France Unbowed) party. But the calls have been in vain. If the government has kept a low profile, it has also avoided debating the issue. 

“French arms exports are the subject of annual reports sent to parliament,” said the prime minister’s office in a written reply to Disclose (click on the "MORE" tab top of page for the full statement). “These reports are public.” But that comment omitted to mention that the information contained in those reports does not detail the type of equipment sold, the manufacturer, or the quantity which is exported.

Contrary to Germany, another major weapons exporter to Saudi Arabia and which has recently put in place an embargo on further arms supplies to the kingdom, France continues with its arms supplies to the country, and it does so in decisions taken behind closed doors.

Before signing a contract such as ARTIS, Nexter was required to first obtain an export licence from France’s general directorate of armament, the DGA, which is part of the defence ministry. Subsequently, such contracts must be approved by the CIEEMG, a special commission that sits under the authority of the French prime minister’s office. In making its decision, the CIEEMG is supposed to take account of “the interior situation of the country that is the final destination [of the weapons], and also of its practices regarding the respect of human rights”.

Questioned, the CIEEMG said that, "The risks for the civilian population are obviously at the top of the criteria for examination that are taken into account".

The export application is then submitted before the French prime minister who, alone, can deliver a final stamp of approval.

Contacted by Disclose, the French prime minister's office provided a lengthy reply to the issuess raised in this, and our adjoining reports, published by Mediapart on April 15th. The most relevant statements have been included in the three arcticles, while the full reply, translated from French into English, can be found by clicking on the "More" tab (here, or top of page)

-------------------------

  • The French version of this report can be found here.

-------------------------

If you have information of public interest you would like to pass on to Mediapart for investigation you can contact us at this email address: enquete@mediapart.fr. If you wish to send us documents for our scrutiny via our highly secure platform please go to https://www.frenchleaks.fr/ which is presented in both English and French.

-------------------------

Si vous avez des informations à nous communiquer, vous pouvez nous contacter à l’adresse enquete@mediapart.fr. Si vous souhaitez adresser des documents en passant par une plateforme hautement sécurisée, vous pouvez vous connecter au site frenchleaks.fr.

Extend your reading on Mediapart Unlimited access to the Journal free contribution in the Club Subscribe

Disclose is a new French entity in online media, established as an NGO dedicated to investigative journalism. It is a not-for-profit project, uniquely financed from voluntary funding. Its investigations are carried out over long-term assignments, before their publication on its freely accessible site, in conjunction with other media partners.

Mediapart is one of its partners, with the intention of supporting new media projects in investigative journalism, which is why we are relaying here the first major series of reports by Disclose, with the selection of three articles. They provide exclusive and further irrefutable evidence of a scandal which Mediapart has previously reported upon, namely the role played by French-made weapons in the dirty war waged in Yemen by the Saudi- and Emirati-led coalition.

The documents revealed by Disclose include those classified in France as official defence secrets. If we detail them here it is because they are of public interest. They demonstrate how the French government has concealed its part of responsibility in a war which, since 2015, has caused the deaths of thousands of civilians.

The publication of these documents represents no danger to French army personnel nor its missions. The subject here is the use of weapons made and sold by France to other countries.

Some of the information contained in these three reports by Disclose is from several entities monitoring the crisis in Yemen.

One is the Yemen Data Project, a not-for-profit initiative set up in 2016 to provide independently researched facts and figures about the unfolding war in Yemen, including unbiased data relating to the coalition’s bombing campaigns. The information it receives is studied and compared against other data collected by the UK-based NGO Armed Conflict Location & Event Data Project (ACLED).

Other data cited in this investigation comes from publicly accessible information provided by the UN Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), the World Health Organization (WHO), and the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC), a body partnered by UN agencies, governments and NGOs to provide analyses of situations of food insecurity and malnutrition.